Two offers can look equally generous to a shopper. “20% off everything” and “Spend $100, get a $20 gift card” both seem to give $20 back on a $100 order. For the merchant, they behave very differently: one cuts the price today, the other gives credit that brings the customer back later.

This guide compares a bonus gift card with a bigger discount as a BFCM offer, looking at cash flow, margin, redemption, average order value, and retention. If you are building your holiday promotions, you can set up discounts and gift cards on Shopify and test both approaches.

How Each Offer Works

The difference starts with when the value reaches the customer.

A discount gives value now

The shopper pays less at checkout. You collect less revenue on that order, and the value is used immediately.

A bonus gift card gives value later

The shopper pays full price today and receives store credit to use on a future order. You collect full revenue now, and the credit only costs you when it is redeemed.

Shopify supports both

Shopify’s Help Center explains that merchants can issue free gift cards manually or automatically with Shopify Flow, using an order trigger and an issue gift card action, which suits promotions such as rewarding a minimum spend (Source: Shopify Help Center).

Person holding a white gift card

Image source: Unsplash.

Side-by-Side Comparison

The table below summarizes how the two offers usually compare. Your results depend on your margins and customers.

Factor 20% discount Spend $X, get $Y gift card
Cash collected today Lower Full price
Margin on first order Reduced immediately Protected on first order
Appeal to deal seekers Very high Moderate
Encourages higher spend Only if tiered Yes, through the threshold
Brings customers back Not directly Yes, through redemption
Accounting complexity Simple Creates outstanding gift card balances

Cash Flow and Margin

For many small brands, the cash difference matters as much as the margin difference.

Full revenue during your busiest week

BFCM is when you pay for inventory, ads, and extra staff. Collecting full price helps cash flow at exactly the moment costs peak.

The credit has a cost when used

A redeemed $20 gift card is $20 of product given away on a later order. The cost does not disappear, it moves to a quieter month when you may have more margin room.

Gift cards are a liability until used

Shopify notes that gift cards can create a liability to provide future sales and appear in gift card finance reports. Talk to your accountant about how outstanding balances should be recorded.

Worked Example With Illustrative Numbers

These figures are hypothetical. Use your own costs and redemption data.

Option A: 20% off a $100 order

Product cost is $40. The shopper pays $80, and you keep $40 before shipping, fees, and ads. Every discounted order carries this reduced margin.

Option B: $20 gift card on a $100 order

The shopper pays $100 and you keep $60 before other costs. If the gift card is redeemed later, the next order carries a $20 reduction. If that next order is $70 with $28 product cost, you keep $22 on it before other costs.

What changes the outcome

Option B looks stronger when customers return and spend more than the card value. It looks weaker if shoppers find the offer less exciting and fewer of them buy in the first place. A test is the only reliable way to know for your store.

Create BFCM Offers With Shopify

Partnered with Shopify: This guide includes Shopify links for merchants structuring holiday discounts, gift cards, and automations.

How Shoppers Perceive Each Offer

An offer only works if shoppers understand and value it.

Discounts are instantly clear

“20% off” needs no explanation. Shoppers comparing prices across stores respond to it quickly, which is why it remains the default BFCM offer.

Gift cards need clear terms

Shoppers want to know when the card arrives, when it can be used, and whether it expires. Unclear terms make the offer feel like a catch.

Gift cards fit gift buyers well

A shopper buying holiday gifts can treat the bonus card as a reward for themselves, or even pass it on. That makes the offer feel more personal than a percentage off.

Setting Fair Gift Card Terms

Good terms make the offer attractive while keeping it manageable.

Choose a redemption window carefully

Some stores allow redemption starting in January to bring customers back after the holidays. Shopify notes that expiry dates are optional and that some regions may not allow them, so check local gift card laws before setting expiration.

Set the spend threshold above current average order value

If your average order is $70, a “spend $100” threshold encourages shoppers to add an item. Setting it below your average simply rewards orders you would have received anyway.

Watch currency settings for international stores

Shopify’s Help Center explains how gift cards issued in store currency or local currency behave at checkout. If you sell in several currencies, decide which approach suits your markets before launch.

When Each Offer Usually Fits Better

The right answer depends on your goal for the season.

Choose a discount when

You need to clear inventory, you sell mostly to price-sensitive shoppers, or your products are often compared directly with identical items elsewhere.

Choose a gift card when

You want repeat purchases in January, your products have strong reorder potential, or you want to protect cash and first-order margin during BFCM.

Combine them carefully

Some stores run a modest discount plus a gift card for orders above a high threshold. Keep the structure simple enough to explain in one line.

Shopper looking at a laptop while holding a card

Image source: Unsplash.

Automate and Measure the Offer

A gift card offer only pays off if you track what happens after BFCM.

Automate issuing with Shopify Flow

Set a Flow workflow that issues the gift card when an order meets the threshold. Test it with a sample order before the sale.

Send a reminder before cards expire or when redemption opens

Customers forget about store credit. A short email when the card becomes usable can lift redemption and bring them back.

Track redemption and second-order value

Measure how many cards are redeemed, the average value of redemption orders, and whether those customers buy again. These numbers tell you whether to repeat the offer next year.

Mistakes That Weaken Either Offer

Both offers can fail for reasons that have little to do with the offer itself.

Hiding the gift card terms

If shoppers only learn the redemption window after checkout, the offer feels misleading. Put the key terms on the banner, product pages, and cart, in the same words each time.

Stacking offers by accident

A store-wide discount, a gift card bonus, and an email code can combine into far more than you planned. Review discount combination settings and test orders that use several offers at once.

Forgetting the January customer experience

Gift card redemption orders arrive when stock may be low and teams are tired after the season. Make sure popular products are available and that redemption works on mobile before sending the reminder email.

Judging the result too early

A gift card offer may show lower BFCM conversion but stronger January sales. Wait until the redemption window closes before deciding which offer performed better. You can compare discount and gift card reports in Shopify across both periods.

Black Friday sale sign

Image source: Unsplash.

BFCM Offer Checklist

Confirm these points before you choose.

  • Know your contribution margin at full price and with each offer.
  • Set the gift card threshold above your current average order value.
  • Check local rules on gift card expiry.
  • Write terms in one or two plain sentences.
  • Automate issuing with Shopify Flow and test it.
  • Plan a reminder email for gift card redemption.
  • Decide how you will measure success after the season.

When you are ready, build the offer in your Shopify admin and run a test order end to end.

Set Up Gift Card Rewards on Shopify

Final Thoughts

A bigger discount wins on instant appeal, while a bonus gift card protects cash and first-order margin and gives customers a reason to return. Choose based on your goal for the season, set a threshold above your average order value, write clear terms, and track redemption afterward. Use Shopify’s discounts and gift cards to test both and keep the offer that performs better on profit, not just orders.

FAQ

Can Shopify issue gift cards automatically for BFCM orders?

Yes. Shopify’s Help Center describes using Shopify Flow with an order trigger and an issue gift card action.

Do bonus gift cards need an expiry date?

No. Shopify makes expiry optional, and some regions restrict expiry dates, so check local gift card laws first.

Is a gift card offer cheaper than a discount?

Not automatically. It shifts the cost to a later order and only pays off if enough customers return and spend more than the card value.

We only recommend tools we’ve tested and trust. This post may include affiliate links, meaning we may earn a commission if you choose to purchase – at no extra cost to you.