When a shopper browses your collection page, your merchandising decides what they see first. When the same shopper asks an AI assistant for help, the assistant decides. Your job shifts from arranging products on a page to giving the assistant enough reasons to pick the right ones.
Shopify’s 2026 holiday research found that 65% of shoppers plan to use AI for at least one shopping task this season (Source: Shopify). This article looks at what that data means for Shopify product merchandising: which products to emphasize, how to structure price tiers and bundles, and how to make niche products easier to find. If you are planning holiday assortment now, you can manage collections and products on Shopify while you apply these ideas.
What the Holiday Data Actually Says
The headline number is useful, but the details matter more for merchandising decisions.
AI is mostly a research tool for now
Shopify’s report notes that most shoppers use AI to research products but stop short of letting an agent complete the purchase. Only about one-third said they trusted an agent to buy for them. Merchandising for AI is therefore mainly about making the shortlist.
Shoppers want considered purchases
According to the same report, 81% of shoppers who use AI regularly say they are choosing more products that feel personal, intentional, or considered. And 35% say they choose the best version for their needs even if it is not the cheapest.
Independent brands get a look
Shopify reports that 71% of regular AI users are more likely to choose an independent brand this year than last. AI research can surface smaller brands that would not appear on the first page of a marketplace.
What This Means for Merchandising
Read together, these findings point to a few clear shifts.
| Finding | Merchandising implication |
|---|---|
| Most shoppers research with AI | Product data must explain fit, use, and value without your page layout |
| Shoppers want considered products | Highlight what makes each item specific, not just popular |
| Best version over cheapest | State clearly why a premium tier is worth it |
| Openness to independent brands | Niche and specialist products deserve better descriptions |
| Agents compare mainly on price | Non-price reasons to buy must be written down |

Image source: Unsplash.
Assortment Decisions for AI-Assisted Shoppers
AI research does not mean you need more products. It often means you need clearer ones.
Prioritize products that answer specific needs
Shopify’s report notes that agentic search rewards brands that solve specific customer problems. A “travel-size grooming kit for carry-on bags” answers a clearer need than a generic gift set.
Trim near-duplicates
Five similar candles with vague names make it harder for an assistant to choose. Fewer, better-differentiated products with distinct descriptions are easier to recommend.
Give niche products a fair chance
Specialist items often struggle on collection pages because they rarely make the bestseller grid. In AI research, a shopper describing an unusual need can be matched to that niche product directly, if its description explains the use case.
Structuring Price Tiers With Clear Reasons
Because agents compare mainly on price, your tiers need explicit reasons to choose each level.
Good, better, best with stated differences
If you sell three versions of the same product, write down exactly what changes between them: material, capacity, warranty, or included accessories. “Premium” alone gives an assistant nothing to compare.
Match tiers to common budget ceilings
Gift shoppers often set limits such as under $25, $50, or $100. If a product sits at $52, consider whether a smaller variant or bundle could land under a common ceiling without hurting margin.
Explain the premium honestly
The 35% who choose the best version need a reason to do so. Longevity, better materials, or repairability are concrete reasons. Vague luxury language is not.
Partnered with Shopify: This guide includes Shopify links for merchants organizing products, collections, and catalog data for the holiday season.
Attributes and Context That Help Products Get Picked
Merchandising for AI research happens inside your product data.
Add structured attributes
Use product metafields for attributes shoppers describe: material, size, scent family, compatibility, skill level, or care needs. Structured data is easier to reuse across collections, filters, and channels.
Write context, not slogans
A description that says “for home cooks who want restaurant-style searing on a gas stove” gives an assistant a match. “Elevate your kitchen” does not.
Keep Catalog data aligned
Shopify Catalog structures product data for AI channels. Shopify’s Help Center explains how merchants can map which title and description Catalog uses (Source: Shopify Help Center). Review those settings for your holiday bestsellers.
Bundles and Gift Sets in an AI Context
Bundles can help or confuse, depending on how clearly they are described.
Describe who the bundle is for
“Beginner pour-over kit for someone switching from instant coffee” is easy to match. “Coffee bundle #3” is not.
List what is included in plain text
Assistants read text more reliably than images. List each component and its size in the description, not only in a product photo.
Show the value without inflating it
If the bundle costs less than buying items separately, say how much less based on real current prices. Avoid reference prices you never actually charged.

Image source: Unsplash.
What Shopify’s Brand Examples Suggest
Shopify’s report shares results from brands that invested in this kind of visibility.
AI-referred sales are growing for some brands
The report says ILIA’s AI-referred sales nearly tripled year over year, and Cottonique’s AI-referred sales grew 276% year over year. These are individual brand results, not benchmarks, but they show the channel can matter.
Specific problems, specific products
Cottonique sells products for people with skin sensitivities, a clear and specific need. That kind of positioning is easier for AI research to match than broad lifestyle messaging.
Emotional reasons must be visible
Shopify’s report also notes that emotional connection and values need to be stated where agents can find them. A brand story only on the About page may never reach an AI answer.
Worked Example: A Tea Shop Reworks Its Holiday Range
A small online tea shop shows how these ideas fit together in practice.
The starting point
The shop listed 14 holiday teas with names like “Winter Glow” and “Snowfall,” each described in a short, poetic paragraph. Three gift tins sat at $48, $52, and $58, and the difference between them was only visible in photos.
The changes
The team merged two near-identical spiced blends, added “black tea,” “caffeine-free,” or “green tea” to every title, and wrote one sentence per product about who it suits, such as “for someone who drinks tea in the evening and wants to avoid caffeine.” They repriced the smallest tin to land under a $50 ceiling and listed the contents of each tin in text.
What they watch
Over the next few weeks, the shop compares visits and orders from AI-referred traffic with the same weeks last season, checks which teas assistants mention when prompted, and reviews whether the caffeine-free range sells better now that its key attribute is written down.
None of these steps requires new products or new tools. They make existing products easier to understand, which is what AI-assisted shoppers need. You can bulk edit product titles and descriptions in Shopify to apply similar changes across a range.
Merchandising Mistakes to Avoid
Some old habits work against AI-assisted shoppers.
- Relying on badges and banners to explain value, since AI tools read text more than visuals.
- Naming products only with creative names and no product type.
- Keeping several near-identical products with copy-pasted descriptions.
- Using inflated compare-at prices that do not reflect real past prices.
- Leaving out sizes, materials, or compatibility details from descriptions.
Holiday Merchandising Checklist
Use this list on your top holiday products before peak weeks.
- Each product states its product type and the specific need it solves.
- Price tiers explain what changes between versions.
- Key attributes sit in metafields, not only in images.
- Bundles list contents and the intended recipient.
- Catalog mapping uses the clearest title and description.
- Niche products have descriptions as detailed as bestsellers.
When the list is done, review your Shopify catalog once more and test a few realistic AI prompts for your category.

Image source: Unsplash.
Final Thoughts
With 65% of holiday shoppers planning to use AI, Shopify product merchandising shifts from arranging pages to explaining products clearly. Focus on specific needs, clear price tiers, structured attributes, and honest bundles so AI tools can shortlist the right items. Treat brand results as signals rather than promises, and use Shopify’s catalog tools to keep your product data clear across every channel.
FAQ
Does AI shopping make collection pages less important?
No. Shopify’s research shows most shoppers still complete purchases themselves, often on your site, so collections and navigation still matter.
Should I cut products to make AI recommendations easier?
Not necessarily. Focus on removing near-duplicates and improving descriptions so each product has a clear, distinct purpose.
Where does the 65% figure come from?
It comes from Shopify’s 2026 Global Holiday Retail Report, cited in Shopify’s October 2026 agentic holiday article.
We only recommend tools we’ve tested and trust. This post may include affiliate links, meaning we may earn a commission if you choose to purchase – at no extra cost to you.


